What we Mean by "Penal Substitution" | Lent Devotional Day 5

Lent 2026 DevotionalCore | Exploring the Meaning of Jesus’ Death
February 22, 2026 
Written by: Charity Goodwin

What We Mean by “Penal Substitution”

Scripture:

Romans 3:23 All have sinned and fall short of God’s glory, 24 but all are treated as righteous freely by his grace because of a ransom that was paid by Christ Jesus. 25 Through his faithfulness, God displayed Jesus as the place of sacrifice where mercy is found by means of his blood. He did this to demonstrate his righteousness in passing over sins that happened before, 26 during the time of God’s patient tolerance. He also did this to demonstrate that he is righteous in the present time, and to treat the one who has faith in Jesus as righteous.

Romans 3:23–26
 
Reflection:

Penal substitution is a way of naming the good news that, in Jesus, God deals honestly with sin and fully with mercy. “Penal” points to the reality that sin has penalties or consequences such as real harm, real rupture, real injustice. “Substitution” means Christ stands in our place. The claim is not that God is reluctant to forgive, but that God’s forgiveness is costly. God absorbs the cost of repairing what we cannot repair.
If you’ve ever felt stuck wanting to change but unable, penal substitution insists that grace meets you before you can perform your way into freedom.

Prayer:  

Jesus, there are places in my life where I try to fix it all, without your help or counsel. Help me today to lean on you knowing your love is so big you want to repair my screw ups. May I open myself to your forgiveness.

Reflection Question:

Where do you feel the weight of “I should be able to fix this,” and what would it mean to let Christ be “for you” there?

Sign up to receive the Lenten Devotional straight to your inbox here.