April 17th, 2022
by Tyler Curtis
by Tyler Curtis
by Kelley Weber

Scroll to the bottom of the post for the video overview!
Heresy or Doctrine?
I feel like we could totally use a gameshow called “Heresy or Doctrine?”
The host makes a statement, then the contestants push their buzzer - Heresy if they think the statement is categorically false, and doctrine if they think there’s scripture to support the statement.”
We might be surprised by what the contestants think..
Let’s play.
Here’s your first statement: We human beings are Divine.
Heresy or Doctrine? Go ahead, push your imaginary buzzers.
Ready for the answer? That’s a true statement. Yup! We humans have the spark of divinity in us.
“I have been crucified with Christ and I no longer live, but Christ lives in me. The life I now live in the body, I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.” (Galatians 2:20)
Now here’s what that statement does NOT mean -
Here’s what the statement DOES mean -
I know; still a lot to wrap your mind around. I think of it this way:learning about who God is – and who we are in relation to God – is like finding pieces to a puzzle The more pieces we find, the bigger we realize the puzzle is! God is not unknowable, but rather endlessly knowable.
Seems mysterious, right? How do we talk about Mystery? Well, let’s start with the Poets, Mystics, and Prophets of old to point us towards language that helps us understand the Mysteries of God.
The host makes a statement, then the contestants push their buzzer - Heresy if they think the statement is categorically false, and doctrine if they think there’s scripture to support the statement.”
We might be surprised by what the contestants think..
Let’s play.
Here’s your first statement: We human beings are Divine.
Heresy or Doctrine? Go ahead, push your imaginary buzzers.
Ready for the answer? That’s a true statement. Yup! We humans have the spark of divinity in us.
“I have been crucified with Christ and I no longer live, but Christ lives in me. The life I now live in the body, I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.” (Galatians 2:20)
Now here’s what that statement does NOT mean -
- It does not mean you are God.
- It does not mean that Christians are divine and other religions are not.
- It does not mean that your divinity is the same as Jesus’ divinity.
Here’s what the statement DOES mean -
- It means that you are created in the image of God. You are made of “Godstuff.”
- It means that God is revealed in and through your actions in the world. You are an ambassador of the divine.
- It means that you are anointed in the same spirit of the Christ as Jesus. While Jesus was the perfect manifestation of the Christ, your journey will always endeavor to follow Jesus. You may never do this perfectly, but there’s comfort in the fact that you are on the same path that Jesus himself followed.
I know; still a lot to wrap your mind around. I think of it this way:learning about who God is – and who we are in relation to God – is like finding pieces to a puzzle The more pieces we find, the bigger we realize the puzzle is! God is not unknowable, but rather endlessly knowable.
Seems mysterious, right? How do we talk about Mystery? Well, let’s start with the Poets, Mystics, and Prophets of old to point us towards language that helps us understand the Mysteries of God.
What do the scholars say?
First, here’s a prophetic voice from the book of Acts chapter 17:
“The God who made the world and everything in it is the Lord of heaven and earth and does not live in temples built by human hands. And is not served by human hands, as if God needs anything. Rather, God gives…everything! ‘For in God we live and move and have our being.’As some of your own poets have said, ‘We are the offspring of the Divine.’”
Meister Eckhart, medieval German philosopher and mystic, also described our connection to the Divine.
“When man is created, God is revealed. God is not outside one’s self but as one’s self and in one’s self. Eckhart would say that it is equally true that we exist within God as God exists within us. ‘For in God we live and move and have our being.’”
It’s like God is the artist and we are the artwork. The two are separate entities but they are deeply reliant on each other. The artwork does not exist without the artist and the artist is not made known except through their art. There is a unity to their existence.
Eckhart says, “The eye with which I see God is the same eye with which God sees me: my eye and God’s eye are one eye, one seeing, one knowing, and one love.”
Finally, in his poem Hagia Sophia, Trappist monk and writer Thomas Merton expresses this Oneness as a paradox where God is the “hidden wholeness” found within our fragmented and very human selves.
“There is in all visible things an invisible fecundity, a
dimmed light, a meek namelessness, a hidden whole-
ness. This mysterious Unity and Integrity is Wisdom,
the Mother of all, Natura naturans. There is in all
things an inexhaustible sweetness and purity, a silence
that is a fount of action and joy. It rises up in word-
less gentleness and flows out to me from the unseen
roots of all created being, welcoming me tenderly,
saluting me with indescribable humility. This is at
once my own being, my own nature, and the Gift of
my Creator's Thought and Art within me, speaking
as Hagia Sophia, speaking as my sister, Wisdom.”
“The God who made the world and everything in it is the Lord of heaven and earth and does not live in temples built by human hands. And is not served by human hands, as if God needs anything. Rather, God gives…everything! ‘For in God we live and move and have our being.’As some of your own poets have said, ‘We are the offspring of the Divine.’”
Meister Eckhart, medieval German philosopher and mystic, also described our connection to the Divine.
“When man is created, God is revealed. God is not outside one’s self but as one’s self and in one’s self. Eckhart would say that it is equally true that we exist within God as God exists within us. ‘For in God we live and move and have our being.’”
It’s like God is the artist and we are the artwork. The two are separate entities but they are deeply reliant on each other. The artwork does not exist without the artist and the artist is not made known except through their art. There is a unity to their existence.
Eckhart says, “The eye with which I see God is the same eye with which God sees me: my eye and God’s eye are one eye, one seeing, one knowing, and one love.”
Finally, in his poem Hagia Sophia, Trappist monk and writer Thomas Merton expresses this Oneness as a paradox where God is the “hidden wholeness” found within our fragmented and very human selves.
“There is in all visible things an invisible fecundity, a
dimmed light, a meek namelessness, a hidden whole-
ness. This mysterious Unity and Integrity is Wisdom,
the Mother of all, Natura naturans. There is in all
things an inexhaustible sweetness and purity, a silence
that is a fount of action and joy. It rises up in word-
less gentleness and flows out to me from the unseen
roots of all created being, welcoming me tenderly,
saluting me with indescribable humility. This is at
once my own being, my own nature, and the Gift of
my Creator's Thought and Art within me, speaking
as Hagia Sophia, speaking as my sister, Wisdom.”
Mysterious You: In review!
So, to sum up:
- You are made of Godstuff.
- You reveal God’s self, as you are created by God. Art and Artist.
- Though you are not perfect (like Jesus), but bear the burden of a fragmented self, within each of us is a hidden wholeness - a True Self - borne out of the image of God, that is as accessible to you as your own breath.
Want more content like this?
Want to stay up to date when a new blog, podcast, or video drops? Follow us below and get weekly updates with all-new content from The Gathering!
Posted in The Hub
Posted in faith, creation, meister eckhart, Divine Love, thomas merton, acts, kelley weber
Posted in faith, creation, meister eckhart, Divine Love, thomas merton, acts, kelley weber
Recent
Visio Divina | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 26
March 30th, 2025
Spring Forward in Faith // M-Note 3.29.25
March 29th, 2025
Ain’t Got Nothin’ | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 25
March 29th, 2025
Emotional Rollercoaster Discussion Guide - Part 4
March 28th, 2025
i flipped a table once | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 24
March 28th, 2025
Archive
2025
January
Happy New Year // M-Note 1.4.2025Cancel the Noise // M-Note 1.11.25Cancel the Noise Discussion Guide - Part 1The Beloved Community // M-Note 01.18.2025Cancel the Noise Discussion Guide - Part 2What A Coincidence // M-Note 1.25.25Cancel the Noise Discussion Guide - Part 3Cancel the Noise Discussion Guide - Part 4The Original Influencer // M-Note 2.1.25
February
The Beloved Community Discussion Guide - Part 1Exploring New Sites…And You’re Invited // M-Note 2.8.25The Beloved Community Discussion Guide - Part 2Uncovering Implicit Bias // M-Note 2.15.2025A "Flurry" of Activity // M-Note 2.22.25The Beloved Community Discussion Guide - Part 3The Beloved Community Discussion Guide - Part 4
March
Beloved Community Action Steps // M-Note 3.1.25Vulnerability & Wilderness | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 1Trusting the Spirit's Lead | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 2Courageous Connection | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 3What's Your Emotional IQ? // M-Note 3.8.25The Spaces Between Us | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 4Emotional Rollercoaster Discussion Guide - Part 1Jesus Weeps With You | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 5When Sadness Lingers | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 6Lurking in the Shadows | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 7Cycles of Life and Death | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 8Inked in Memory | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 9The Void of Grief | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 10Sending Forth // M-Note 3.15.25Emotional Rollercoaster Discussion Guide - Part 2Journey Not Alone | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 11Friends Along the Way | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 12The Loneliness of Fear | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 13Not Through With You Yet | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 14Clinging to Hope | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 15Bring It To The King | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 16Pray When Unsteady | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 17Courage to Stand for Faith | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 18Emotional Rollercoaster Discussion Guide - Part 3A Holy Rage | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 19Focus on What is Holy | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 20Fast for Justice and Kindness | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 21The World is Harsh and Beautiful | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 22I Feel Sorry for Jesus | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 23Emotional Rollercoaster Discussion Guide - Part 4i flipped a table once | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 24Ain’t Got Nothin’ | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 25Spring Forward in Faith // M-Note 3.29.25Visio Divina | 2025 Lenten Devotional | Day 26
2024
January
Clean Slate: Week 1 Discussion GuideStarting & Sustaining Change // M-Note 1.6.24Clean Slate: Week 2 Discussion GuideStarting Small, Dreaming Big // M-Note 1.13.24Clean Slate: Week 3 Discussion GuideTogether Towards Change...and Healthy Habits // M-Note 1.20.24Clean Slate: Week 4 Discussion GuideSlowing Down for God to Show Up // M-Note 1.27.24
February
More Isn't Always Better // M-Note 2.3.24Money Talks: Week 1 Discussion GuideAshes for Valentine's Day? // M-Note 2.10.24Money Talks: Week 2 Discussion GuideLenten Devotional 2024Money Talks: Week 3 Discussion GuideWhat's your legacy? // M-Note 2.17.24Strength in Numbers: Community in Ministry // M-Note 2.24.24Entourage Discussion Guide - Week One
March
Entourage Discussion Guide - Week TwoUpdates from Clayton and Easter Invitation // M-Note 3.2.24Twenty Students Confirmed Last Sunday // M-Note 3.9.24Entourage Discussion Guide - Week 3How serving at Easter can really make a difference // M-Note 3.16.24Entourage Discussion Guide - Week 4Can You Know Joy Without Pain? // M-Note 3.23.24Entourage Discussion Guide - Week 5It's time for EasterSTL at The Factory // M-Note 3.28.24
April
Easter Discussion GuideScreen Time: Troubleshooting our Relationship with Technology // M-Note 4.6.24Screen Time Discussion Guide - Week 1Springtime Reminders: Joy Comes with the Morning // M-Note 4.13.24Screen Time Discussion Guide - Week 2Shaping the Future at the UMC General Conference // M-Note 4.20.24Screen Time Discussion Guide - Week 3 General Conference Halftime Report// M-Note 4.27.24Screen Time Discussion Guide - Week 4
May
Very Good News at the End of General Conference//M-Note 5.4.24Uncomfortable Truths Discussion Guide - Week 1Uncomfortable Truths Discussion Guide - Week 2Announcing The Gathering’s Church Planters Lab//M-Note 5.11.24My (Hypothetical) Commencement Address // M-Note 5.18.24Uncomfortable Truths Discussion Guide - Week 3Uncomfortable Truths Discussion Guide - Week 4
June
No Comments